Butterfinger Pie

You know the saying "Easy as Pie"?  I've never understood it.  Pie is really not that easy, in my humble opinion.

There's the deal with the crust.  Crust really brings on the stress, because it can make or break a pie.  The PRESSURE!

However.  This pie.  I really don't believe it could possibly get easier than this pie.  Seriously.  If you mess this up, there may be no hope for you in the kitchen.  Sorry.  I'm sure you are FABULOUS at other things though!

After spending too much time in the kitchen making my Honeycomb Bars, I needed/wanted something quick, and delicious for the Playoff get-together.  Football is the perfect excuse to make all those delicious things you could probably never justify eating on an ordinary day.  Let me just say, if you are dieting, turn run away from this.  I should be dieting, but...

Photo courtesy SydesJokes

Butterfinger Pie
adapted from Food.com
found on Pinterest!

Cookie Mama's Notes:
* You could make this lower-fat by substituting low-fat or fat-free Cool Whip and cream cheese.  If you do this, let me know how it turns out!
* I bought the 16 oz. Cool Whip and weighed out 12 oz.  I'd say remove about 1 1/2 c. from your container, and use the remaining for the pie.
* You could make your own crust, and I'm sure it would be more delicious than the pre-made, but people, I was going the easiest route possible!
* The longer you chill, the easier to cut and serve.
* A normal pie is generally cut into 8 slices.  This pie is rich and sweet!  I recommend smaller pieces and getting at least 10 slices.

- 7 regular (2.1oz) size Butterfingers
- 8 oz. cream cheese, softened
- 12 oz. Cool Whip
- 1 pre-made Graham Cracker Crust

(3 Ingredients?!  Yes!  It is that EASY!)

Crush/Chop 6 Butterfingers.  Add to medium sized bowl with softened cream cheese.  Blend with a hand mixer.  Fold in Cool Whip.  Add to crust.

Chill for at least an hour.  Crush remaining Butterfinger and sprinkle over the top of the pie before serving.


  1. Can't wait to try this one. Thanks! You always find the most delicious things.

  2. Did it tonight with lite Cool Whip and low fat cream cheese. Delightful! Thanks.

  3. on my list for tomorrow

  4. I made 4 of these wonderful pies and they were gone the same night. They were a great hit and everyone loved them. For the kids I also used the small tart grahamcracker shells and they each had their own personal serving.

  5. I made this a couple of weeks ago and it is truly that easy and truly that amazing. I could have eaten the whole pie by myself in one sitting. But I shared. No, really....I shared!

  6. Made this last night & it was amazing. I had to add all the mini butterfingers for more flavor...& I made my own whipping cream. Loved it! ;)

    1. Sounds perfect! Homemade whipped cream is the BEST!

  7. I made this for friends the other night. It was a huge hit. Delicious!!

  8. I made this and OMG!!! so stinking good!!!

  9. I make this for every family gathering everyone loves it actually had a request to make a few for a local pie auction.

  10. I actually use a reg pre made crust and bake it and then put a chocolate coating on the crust once cooled before I put the buttering er mixture in. So delish!

  11. I make this quite often with whatever candy/cookies I have on hand. I thought it needs to be a bit sweeter so I added a half cup sugar to the cream cheese mixture.

  12. I make this quite often with whatever candy/cookies I have on hand. I thought it needs to be a bit sweeter so I added a half cup sugar to the cream cheese mixture.

  13. You actually explained this terrifically!
    Oh my goodness! Awesome article dude! Thanks, Numerous tips!

    Try to check my webpage :: 출장안마